Navigating the Stagnant Spot Truckload Market

At Gain Consulting, we empower U.S. shippers with data-driven insights to thrive in a dynamic supply chain environment. The latest DAT Truckload Volume Index, reported by Logistics Management on May 14, 2025, reveals a persistently stagnant spot truckload market in April, with both volumes and rates showing little movement. This prolonged flatness, described as “truly stuck” by DAT Chief of Analytics Ken Adamo, presents unique challenges and opportunities for shippers. In this blog post, we analyze the current state of the truckload market, explore its implications for U.S. shippers, and provide actionable strategies to optimize your logistics operations in 2025.

The Current State of the Spot Truckload Market

According to the DAT Truckload Volume Index, April 2025 marked another month of stagnation for spot truckload volumes and rates, following a mixed performance in March. The index, which tracks the number of loads with a pickup date each month (normalized to a baseline of 100 from January 2015), showed no significant shifts in activity for dry van, refrigerated (reefer), or flatbed segments. This flatness extends to the contract market, which has remained “absolutely stagnant” for an unprecedented period, as noted by Adamo in an interview with Logistics Management’s Jeff Berman.

Adamo highlighted an “expected backslide” in April, though not to a critical level, emphasizing the surprising lack of volatility. “The biggest surprise is just how truly stuck things are,” he said. “No one’s really seen a period where things have just been absolutely dead, especially if you look at the contract market, it’s just absolutely stagnant and flat.” This prolonged equilibrium, with supply and demand in balance since mid-2024, reflects a market awaiting a significant demand signal to break the deadlock.

The data paints a clear picture: spot market activity is subdued, with load-to-truck ratios showing minimal change. For example, April’s van load-to-truck ratio hovered around 4.1, slightly up from March, while reefer and flatbed ratios remained similarly stable. Contract rates, meanwhile, have been virtually unchanged since August 2023, a two-year period of unprecedented stability. Adamo noted, “If contract rates stay flat through August, they will have been flat for two [consecutive] years… literally to the penny where they were in August 2023.”

Key Takeaway: The spot and contract truckload markets are in a rare state of stagnation, with neither volumes nor rates showing significant movement, creating a challenging environment for shippers seeking cost predictability and capacity reliability.

Contextual Factors Driving Market Stagnation

Several factors contribute to the current market conditions, as outlined in the DAT report and broader industry trends:

1. Economic Uncertainty and Tariff Concerns: Ongoing trade policy debates, including U.S. tariffs on imports from China (10%), Mexico, and Canada (25%), have introduced uncertainty, causing shippers to adopt a cautious approach. Adamo noted that recent optimism around lower U.S.-China tariffs provided some relief, but the market remains sensitive to policy shifts.

2. Seasonal Patterns and Lack of Demand Surge: April typically sees a seasonal uptick in freight activity, but 2025’s lack of momentum reflects a muted peak season. Adamo observed that “seasonality by the end of last week began to exert itself in most of the markets,” but the effect was “very tempered” without a significant drop-off or surge.

3. Capacity Equilibrium: Since mid-2024, truckload capacity and demand have been in a state of equilibrium, with no single event—like hurricanes or port strikes—disrupting the balance for long. Adamo described this as a market where disruptions cause only temporary “blips” before returning to stability.

4. Contract Market Rigidity: The contract market’s flatness, with rates unchanged for nearly two years, reflects shippers’ and carriers’ reluctance to renegotiate amid uncertainty. This has kept pricing power with shippers, as noted in DAT’s analysis of consistent contract pricing over the past 12–15 months.

5. Inventory and Warehousing Pressures: Bonded warehouses and free trade zones are reportedly at capacity, which could lead to a rapid volume increase if inventories are released. Adamo suggested this could “hit a lot faster than initially thought” but noted it’s too early to predict May’s outcomes.

These factors combine to create a market that, while stable, lacks the dynamism needed to drive rate or volume growth. For U.S. shippers, this stagnation translates to predictable costs but limited opportunities for cost savings or capacity expansion without strategic intervention.

Key Takeaway: Economic uncertainty, balanced capacity, and rigid contract rates are locking the truckload market in a stagnant state, requiring shippers to adapt proactively to maintain efficiency.

Implications for U.S. Shippers

The stagnant truckload market has significant implications for U.S. shippers, particularly those managing high-volume freight or relying on spot market capacity for flexibility:

1. Cost Predictability but Limited Savings: Flat contract rates offer budget stability, but the lack of downward pressure on spot rates means shippers may struggle to secure lower-cost capacity in the spot market. The spread between contract and spot van rates, which increased for the fourth consecutive month in April, underscores this challenge.

2. Capacity Availability: With capacity and demand in equilibrium, shippers face no immediate shortages but may encounter constraints if demand surges (e.g., from warehouse inventory releases). Flatbed markets, where 30% of loads move via spot compared to 12–15% for vans and reefers, are particularly sensitive to capacity shifts due to specialized equipment needs.

3. Planning Challenges Amid Uncertainty: Tariff uncertainties and a lack of clear demand signals complicate forecasting. Adamo noted that unlike predictable disruptions (e.g., weather events), current uncertainties like tariff policies are harder to plan around, leading to “wild oscillation” in market expectations.

4. E-Commerce and Retail Pressures: The rise of e-commerce, driving demand for faster delivery models, contrasts with the stagnant truckload market, pushing shippers to optimize last-mile and middle-mile operations. Logistics Management reported that e-commerce growth is disrupting traditional freight methods, requiring innovative solutions.

5. Potential for Rapid Shifts: The maxed-out bonded warehouses and free trade zones suggest a latent demand that could spike volumes if released, potentially tightening capacity and raising spot rates. Shippers must be prepared for sudden market shifts, especially in Q3 2025, when seasonal retail demand typically peaks.

Key Takeaway: Shippers benefit from cost predictability but face challenges in securing cost savings, planning amid uncertainty, and preparing for potential rapid market shifts driven by latent demand.

Strategic Recommendations for U.S. Shippers

To navigate the stagnant truckload market and position for success in 2025, Gain Consulting recommends the following strategies tailored to U.S. shippers:

1. Optimize Carrier Mix for Flexibility: Diversify your carrier portfolio to include both contract and spot market providers. Engage regional carriers and 3PLs like RXO or C.H. Robinson to access spot capacity during demand spikes. Platforms like DAT One can help compare rates and secure capacity in real time.

2. Leverage Technology for Visibility: Implement a Transportation Management System (TMS) to monitor rates, track performance metrics (e.g., on-time delivery), and optimize carrier selection. AI-driven tools can forecast demand and identify cost-saving opportunities, particularly for van and reefer freight. Logistics Management highlights the role of SCM software as “connective tissue” in integrated supply chains.

3. Monitor Policy and Market Signals: Stay informed on tariff developments through resources like the U.S. Trade Representative or industry reports from FTR and BlueGrace Logistics. Adamo’s optimism about lower U.S.-China tariffs suggests potential relief, but shippers should prepare for volatility by modeling multiple scenarios.

4. Build Contingency Plans for Volume Surges: Prepare for potential inventory releases from bonded warehouses by securing capacity commitments with carriers. Negotiate flexible contract terms (e.g., 12–18 months vs. 6 months) to balance cost and availability, as suggested by DAT’s analysis of evolving contract terms.

5. Enhance E-Commerce Capabilities: Optimize packaging and routing for lightweight, high-frequency e-commerce shipments to leverage cost advantages in the van market. Partner with Gain Consulting to design last-mile strategies that integrate with carriers like UPS or Amazon Logistics for rural deliveries.

6. Negotiate Strategically in the Contract Market: With contract rates flat, push for value-added services (e.g., enhanced tracking or guaranteed capacity) rather than rate reductions. Adamo noted shippers hold pricing power, giving leverage to secure favorable terms without disrupting relationships.

7. Engage Industry Networks: Join associations like the Council of Supply Chain Management Professionals (CSCMP) or Parcel Shippers Association to gain insights into market trends and advocate for shipper-friendly policies. Collaborative networks can provide early warnings of capacity constraints or rate shifts.

8. Invest in Resilience: As Logistics Management’s 2024 State of Logistics report advises, “rekindle strategic projects and improve resilience” to navigate uncertainty. Invest in warehouse automation or cross-docking to reduce reliance on spot market capacity during peak periods.

Key Takeaway: Shippers should diversify carriers, leverage technology, monitor policy shifts, and build resilience to navigate stagnation and prepare for potential market surges.

How Gain Consulting Can Support Your Success

At Gain Consulting, we specialize in helping U.S. shippers turn challenges into opportunities. Our tailored solutions address the complexities of the 2025 truckload market:

• Carrier Strategy Optimization: Develop a balanced portfolio of contract and spot carriers to ensure cost efficiency and capacity availability.

• Technology Integration: Deploy TMS and AI tools to enhance visibility, optimize routing, and reduce costs, with seamless integration into your operations.

• Market Intelligence: Provide real-time updates on tariff policies, capacity trends, and DAT Truckload Volume Index insights to inform your strategy.

• E-Commerce Solutions: Design agile, cost-effective strategies for e-commerce fulfillment, leveraging van and last-mile carriers.

• Negotiation Support: Guide contract negotiations to secure favorable terms and value-added services without compromising carrier relationships.

• 
  

The stagnant spot truckload market of April 2025, as reported by DAT, underscores the need for proactive strategies to maintain efficiency and competitiveness.

Contact Gain Consulting today to build a resilient, future-ready supply chain that thrives in any market condition.

Sources: Logistics Management, May 14, 2025; DAT Truckload Volume Index, April 2025